Saturday, January 03, 2004

Game theory

I confess, someone gave me a copy of Halo over Christmas and now I'm hooked. For those that don't know, Halo is a video game that consists of running around a ring world shooting pretty much everything in sight. Yes, its one of those evil first-person shooter games that supposedly trains young kids to go out and shoot the teacher, their classmates and yes, pretty much everything in sight. And its not the only one I play, I'll list Unreal Tournament and Americas Army as additional exhibits in my confessional.

Ms. Gently finds it ironic that someone who goes to a half dozen anti-war marches in one year, gets very upset over the sight of dead bodies, and generally loathes violence can still stay up half the night shooting all and sundry on the computer. Well I could use that tried and tested explanation "Its just a game!" but there probably has to be something more to it than that. I think I know why I enjoy such games - I think its partly some innate hunter-gatherer gene kicking in (did you ever meet a cat that didn't like to chase small objects?) but mostly something I learned as a kid and at school.

No I didn't go to military school, and I wasn't found and raised by a platoon of Navy Seals. However I was raised in the seventies when every self respecting boy was given cap guns, holsters and was expected to play cowboys and indians, or soldiers at every available opportunity. I distinctly remember the onset of summer at school when the grass playing fields, previously off-limits during winter and spring, suddenly became huge stages for war game after war game played out over lunch time.

Such war games went like this:

At the start of lunch break gangs of boys (and yes it was all boys) would link arms and rove around in a long line chanting something that I still remember but can't really translate to text. As more boys joined the line got longer and longer and it would eventually break up and then sides were picked by two boys. I don't recall what rules were used to determine who picked sides but I do remember it was never me. After that there was a fleeing of teams to opposite ends of the playing field followed by a long game of cat-n-mouse chasing with hand raised, finger pointed and endless "bang-bang you're dead" stuff. Of course there was also endless "I got you first!", "No you didn't I got you first - you're dead" stuff that on occassion ended up with real fights. However for the most part the only damage done was scraped knees and grass stains on our britches. I don't recall that anyone ever really won these games, or that it made any difference. If nothing else it stopped us all sitting around burning bugs with magnifying glasses and running around trying to peek up girls skirts - not that anyone knew why we were supposed to do it. It was just one of those handed down traditions thats what little boys do at lunch time when the playing fields of war were off-limits.

I guess I'm supposed to know better and that I could make a conscious effort not to play such games on my computer. But, you know what? Its just a game. People have always played games of some sort or other, even animals play games. But one thing I've learned in life so far - there are people who know the difference between a game and reality, and there are people who don't. Its always the latter who tend to wreck havoc on the world, forgetting that in real life the losing side bears physical harm, and probably doesn't get up to play the next day, and will hold lasting grudges. For this reason I actually have a lot of problem with people who treat games as if they are real, and as if they really mattered, i.e. they begin to place a signifcant amount of their lifes meaning on the outcome of games. I mean, guys get depressed because you lost your job due to corportate fraud, because the is no free health care, because the government "misspent" your retirement funds, or your full-time employeer doesn't even pay you enough to buy food for you family. But riot on the streets because "your team" that doesn't give a rats-ass about you lost some game? Get real! Its just a game!

Yes, its okay for professional sports people to care if they are good at a game or not, or if their team wins or not. However when ordinary people think its okay to go out and trash their neighborhood just because some team of people (who probably never even lived in their neighborhood) lost, or won for that matter, well that's a problem. The problem is that such team games really have no meaning any more. The players often don't care one iota what the supporters do or how they behave, and the only people who really win when the win are corporations who run these sports teams as a profit center. Even the olympics, formerly a purely amateur event, has become an orgey of winner-takes-it-all mentality tainted by drug abuse and big corporate money.

Just where did the spirit of "its the participation that counts" in sports and games go to? Is the situation in modern sports just a reflection of reality gone bad; where every aspect of life must reflect the competition for dollars, bragging rights and the perpetual chase for position of top-dog?

So, I'll keep my games essentially meaningless, harmless and above all fun to participate in. The day I start taking them seriously I'll know its time to unplug and go cold turkey on the computer games...

Thursday, January 01, 2004

Blog power unleashed

Moments after posting my last entry (well, in the shower actually) I got to thinking about why blogs have been so effective as a filter for noise on the web. While it is true that blogs in themselves generate and propogate quite a bit of noise, it does seem that the net overall effect is a filtering. It is know that most bloggers read and often link to other blogs in their own entries, this has lead to the description of all blogs as the "blogosphere". However a blogger can only read and filter so much information in a day, so even the authors of the most popular blogs lying close to the center of the blogosphere, only generate entries and links to a relatively small number of items per day.

While blogs now number in the millions, the most popular blogs probably number in the thousands, or perhaps only a few hundred. Naturally it all depends how exactly you define "most popular" but I'm talking about the ones in the top one percentile (or less) of the blogs vs. unique visitors per day curve (I'll call these the "alpha-blogs"). That is to say hits are squewed towards a small number of blogs rather than being evenly ditributed. Thus large numbers (millions) have only a few hits per day, but very few have thousands of more hits per day. To be honest I've actually no idea what the distribution curve of blogs vs. number of daily visitors looks like. So far I've only seen statistics on connectivity of blogs (number of inbound links per blog) which is easy to figure out as part of a standard search engine or blog crawler. Since the blog visitors per day statisitcs are not normally published by each one tt would be interesting to find out. Presumably some of the large hosting sites like blogger.com and livejournal has such information for the blogs they host. So if you have a pointer to such statistics and analysis please send it this way.

One could argue that the most popular "alpha-blogs" are just like the relatively few number of TV channels available to the average media consumer. One could also argue that the blogosphere is not unlike the interconnected official news sources that feed off each others output and filter news from small local communities sources up to the big five media conglomerates. These arguments bothered me, since it still seems apparent that the blog phenonmenom is fundamentally different from the mainstream news reporting system.

In the end I decided the fundamental differences are:

1. It is the very nature of blogs and websites that they interconnect and hence people reading them are constantly poking at the edges of their information network, investigating new sources and ultimately migrating their reading time from one place to the next. Imagine if every day when you watched the news from your local CBS affiliate it gave you an easy link to a dozen other news sources and highly recommended them to boot! Well there's no way that is going to happen, TV channels, radios and newspapers never want to lose their views, listeners or readers - they need you to stay with them to boost their popularity so they can make more money from selling you advertising! Indeed it appears that advertising is the antithesis of blogs, and cross-reference (links) is the antithesis of the mainstream media.

2. As a consequence of 1 the central core of the blogosphere is very fluid because blog popularity is based entirely on free and ever changing selection of sites to visit by the readership. This is contrary to the mainstream world - if find you don't like your NBC, CBS or ABC reporting you probably don't have too many alternatives to turn to. Even if you have cable, by the time you've exhausted Fox (okay, stop laughing), CNN, PBS and a few others you're essentially all out of luck. Plus to a large degree these big guys get the bulk of their content based on Reuters, AP and a few foreign feeds for world news. Ditto for newspapers and radio. Yes, you can do a lot better if you go online and find web based versions of all reportage across the world but you'll find that this is not something a great number of people do. Few people check news from more than one source per day or know of more than a handful of web sites that they might get news from.

3. The mainstream news system has connections down to the city level with most cities having at least one local paper, and perhaps if they are large enough a local radio and TV station, although often as not the latter are more regional. So while you may have some media channels addressing smaller communities it seems that it is increasingly common for members of such communities to resort to an internet forum, website, mailing lists or in most recent time blog based communication. This lack of small community representation by the media appears to be an economic problem. It is simply very expensive and time consuming to put together a newspapaer, TV show or run a radio station without making it a full time job and having hard money to throw at the problem. However, as mentioned earlier, almost anyone can create a blog - even if you are without a computer or Internet connection usually a free library card will get you to somewhere that has. Thus the blogosphere is able to deeply penetrate all communities and hence is relatively much larger than the mainstream "mediasphere" and can draw on a much richer pool of information sources and blog creators. Another consequence of the ease of creating blogs is that the ratio of blog readers to blog creators is much lower than mainstream media consumers to creators.

4. Mainly as a corollary of the previous points, blogs are seldom financially inspired. It is true that some people manage to make a living at it but these are a very tiny, tiny fraction of the total. A larger number might put in some small amount of advertising to defray some of their costs. But the vast majority either has no advertising, or just advertising that is put in automatically by their blog or website host and with which they have no connection or direct gain (other than free hosting). This gives bloggers across the world immense freedom to say whatever the hell they like, do it effectively anonymously if they desire, and best of all they never have to worry about whether anyone is actually really reading their blog or not.

I believe that the above points have together created a unqiue news reporting and filtering system that self-selects popularly defined "interesting" news while still leaving the entire gamut of less interesting stuff out there freely available for those that simply care to Google for it. In many ways the blogosphere acts like the search engine Google itself. The very interconnections between Blogs define how important various blogs are at defining what interesting is, and these interconnections evolve over time, as do what is interesting itself. Thus the blogging phenomenom has engaged us all as a giant distributed, dyanamic and human search engine.

Power to the people, but not to the iPod

With the dumbing down of the media the Internet has been a great boom for freedom of speech, now anyone with access to a computer can put up a website and say what they want. The flip side is such messages get drowned out in the noise of countless millions of other websites. However in recent times large networks of interconnected blogs and independent user forums have come to rescue. They have an interesting and unexpected ability to filter out a lot of the noise and amplify even the quietest important message to the level of popular consciousness. So quite often it is now what the popular mass of people think is important that gets propogated, instead of what story some single corporate controlled editor decides to send us.

This effect is how the Neistat Brothers Message From the Neistat Brothers about iPods premature battery problem got widespread publicity and eventually, perhaps, had some effect in causing Apple to instigate a $99 battery replacement policy and extended battery warranty.

Tuesday, December 23, 2003

Center for Consumer hood-winking

Its interesting to see how people with the opposite views from you portray you. As a progressive you can check out the "Center for Conumer Freedom". They have quite an interesting web site with a break down called activist cash of a large number of progressive activist groups, foundations and individuals. For each one there is an overview, list of motivations, financial information, connections to other organizations, news and a "black eye".

There is no doubt some, even a lot of factual truth in the information they provide, however in amongst the lists of funders, actions taken etc. is also a definite and strong marketing pitch by CCF because everything is written on the assumption these organizations are a) wrong, b) corruptted and c) acting against the interests of consumers, heck they even rail against Mothers Against Drunk Driving because: [their] original goal of going after “drunk” drivers has now been replaced by the goal of eliminating any drinking and driving.

Strangely missing from this web site is the kind of information about CCF that they provide on all other organizations. The "About Us" page merely says:

The Center for Consumer Freedom is a nonprofit coalition supported by restaurants, food companies, and consumers working together to promote personal responsibility and protect consumer choices.
Oh. Well that's really informative. How about some more? Strangely they suggest that one has to go search for their non-profit 501(c)(3) filing to find out more. And conveniently:
Many of the companies and individuals who support the Center financially have indicated that they want anonymity as a contributor. They are reasonably apprehensive about privacy and safety, in light of the violence some activist groups have adopted as a "game plan" to impose their views.
So that stopped them from naming even one single person who is supporting them? Not one of those restaurant chains wanted to step forward and lay claim to supporting consumer freedom? Well that's a suprise isn't it!

Well I think I can probably name the #1 contributor to CCF - junk food and huge meat and food processing companies that supply them. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure that out given that the CCF web site is full of TV and press ads criticising efforts to encourage junk food restaurants to be more responsible about how they market the calorie loaded "meals" they sell. Predictably the CCF chase after the lawyers who are trying to bring suits against people like McDonald's, while conveniently forgetting that it took lawyers to bring down the big tabacco companies for selling cigarettes, and lawyers to bring down Goodyear for selling tyres known to be defective. Its sad that sometimes peoples own free will, and the governments legislation are powerless to have an effect on multi-billion dollar industries with their own sticky fingers stuffing wads of cash in the back pockets of government...

For the full scoop on who the CCF really is - the scoop that their "freedom" site was too afraid to publish - check out the truth about the Center for Consumer Freedom.

Wednesday, December 17, 2003

My thoughts exactly

Mark Morford, a famously outspoken columnist at SF Gate, pretty much said it all for me in todays column. Its a timely reminder of the history and both the dollar and human cost of the "military action" so far.

Open season on Diebold

When the finger was first pointed at Diebold in California they clamed they had done nothing wrong. Now its looking like open season on Diebold. One article tells of scads of illegally upgraded machines are located, incorrect procedures and non-use of correct procedures. Another tells of convicted felons in management positions at Diebold. Employees included a cocaine trafficker, a man who conducted fraudulent stock transactions and a programmer jailed for falsifying computer records. Once again Diebold claimed innocence and that all their employees had passed background checks.

Monday, December 15, 2003

The incy wincy tyrant climbed down the spider hole...

Along came the Bush and flushed the spider out.

Which is to say, the war hero pretender GWB got himself a tyrant aka Saddam Hussein. Is that a good thing? Well, its probably the most expensive and bloody arrest of an evil doer the world has ever seen. Discounting Hitler of course because he managed to kill himself before the alied posse got to him. Of course reeling in Dick Cheney for conspiring with Enron will cost us much more than the $60 billion of investments that were wiped out almost over night, and may even take longer than finding Saddam.

Along with several other people I was half suprised they didn't find Dick hiding out in the "spider hole" with Saddam. But then again, perhaps they did, which is why NeoCon Enemy #1 got out alive without a granade burn to show for it.

But aren't we forgetting something here... wasn't, and isn't, Osam bin Laden the Public Enemy #1? Isn't it the case that Hussein never meet with, worked with, or funded Osama and the only common connection between Osama and Saddam is in fact the US Government who met, aided and funded both of them at one time or another?

I guess when the bogey man is dragged out of a hole and he looks no scarier than Walter Matthau on a bad hair day (I wasn't the only one to think this) then I suppose everyone has to suspend disbelif and just praise to Jesus that George Bush saved us from him.

Sunday, December 14, 2003

No win, no fee

One of the things I noticed back in England was that all of a sudden there seem to be commercials for ambulance chasers. You know, the lawyers who flock around accident victims looking for someone to sue. One of the things Brits love to mock the Americans over is their propensity for litigation, not living in a litigious society gives Brits a sense of moral superiority. However the real reason Britain has never been a litgious society is that it was actually illegal for lawyers to work for a client on a no win no fee basis. This meant, for all intents and purposes, that only the wealthiest people could afford to sue anyone, even for really obvious things. But now it seems that changes to the law allow this and hence the commercials for ambulance chasers on TV and a marked increase in Brits looking for someone to sue.

As a Brit one of the consequences of living in the USA for ten years now is I find myself increasingly adopting a litigious attitude. I suppose its better than wanting to settle things "outside" as it were, after all the law is supposed to be there to protect those unable or unwilling to fight physically for protection. This increasing desire to find people to sue is somewhat bothersome to me, however I believe I have found a great example where a class action suit seems to just the ticket and all it is waiting for is an enterprising firm of lawyers ready to bite the bullet.

I think that there should be a class action suit for regular car owners against car companies for promoting safety of SUV class vehicles at the expense and personal risk of regular car drivers. As I've pointed out before, in a side impact of car vs SUV the car driver is six times more likely to die than in a car to car collision. The net consequence of this is that car drivers end up paying higher insurance rates than SUV owners because their cars are now statistically less safe (oh, and they die more often of course). There's some very contorted and misleading logic going on here that allows auto companies to market and promote SUVs as safer while not being required to mention the net effect on regular car drivers. Just like with the tabacco industry, I think its the kind of thing that only the fear of grave financial injury can persuade the auto companies to change their ways.

Of course while I'm on the subject it goes without saying I should mention that Detroit and Texas love SUVs because a) being essentially low tech beasts, they have much higher profit margins than regular cars, and b) they guzzle more gas than they should if some of that profit margin was pumped into building more fuel efficient SUVs. But neither of these things are ones that would probably fuel a successful class action suit - when it comes down to litigation it is only money and consumers in body bags that count.

Saturday, December 13, 2003

Deflating the American dollar Bush style

On my recent trip to Europe I came to realize just how far the mighty dollar has sunk. Since two years ago it has devalued 25% against the British Pound, and a whopping 38% against the Euro. Add to that the overall decline in USA economic health and you can see that relative to the rest of the world its quite amazing that our leaders can still hold their head up high and proclaim that everything is going to be alright.

Friday, December 12, 2003

"Death by a thousand cuts" Wal-Mart style

Sometimes the press manages to find a voice. All at once we have three articles in the LA Times (sorry no link, its subscription only), an article in the SF Chronicle and then another in Fast Company. The Fast Company article gives the best run down on how Wal-Mart affects its suppliers, the LA Times ones focus on the people effect. Either way I think they tell all you need to know to make an informed decision about whether to shop at Wal-Mart.

Except... do they?

Just try to balance in your head spending 50-100 billion dollars to aid a small nation like Iraq, with sending equal if not larger amounts to aid overseas countries by buying products from the businesses. It may seem like an unfair apples and oranges comparison but is it really? After all, when it comes down to it, wasn't the major complaint with Iraq (the undiscovered WOMD not-withstanding) that they just weren't buying our commerce based democracy. So if Wal-Mart had somehow managed to find a way to suck Iraqi businesses into their vast all encompasing supply chain do you think we would be at war with them now? Wouldn't the Wal-Mart way be a better way to get cozy with our neighbours than the US Army death-or-glory way?

Probably the biggest beef I have with the Wal-Mart effect is that they feed purely on the all American instinct for shopping and getting the best deal. But Wal-Mart shoppers typically have no idea about what goes on behind the curtain and where most of their products come from and what the consequences of embracing the If they did would they truely shop elsewhere? Do they even have any choice not to? I guess they were doing okay before Wal-Mart comes along, and briefly afterwards (as one comment about the Fast Company attests) they may find themselves continuing to spend the same or more but buying even more. Wow - more bang for my buck, isn't Wal-Mart wonderful! However eventually the supply chain squeeze and the lower wages squeeze takes effect and the downward spiral begins to set in.

And finally, all those profits (billions and billions) go into the shareholders pockets, not the workers. Ask yourself this: do you think Wal-Mart would do business with another business as big and profitable as Wal-Mart? No, it would probably tell itself its profit margins were too high and that it should go cut its profits somewhere. But what would that mean to an end of chain seller? It would mean charging lower prices (wow, even lower prices!) or paying its workers and suppliers more. So if Wal-Mart is so great why doesn't it become a profit-sharing company and handed out a signifcant amount of it profit as a dividend to its employees and shoppers - just like REI does at the end of the year. That might go some way to shovel all of that wealth it generates back into the economy and help sustain a viable shopping mass.

Wednesday, December 10, 2003

IQs still dropping sharply

As if on cue the J.D. Powers report on vehicle quality has rated the Hummer H2 dead last. As well as 225 problems per 100 vehicles it turns out that 22% of H2 owners complained about, wait for it.... low gas mileage. Apparently H2 owners are not happy about having to refuel every 200 miles when zipping up and down the freeway in their off-road tanks. Interestingly Hummer has blamed it on a marketing problem instead of buyer stupidity. But it was a cunning exploitation of loopholes that permited Hummer to market the H2 without quoting gas mileage in the first place. It seems unlikely that they will dash to show rooms to brag about the soul and gas sucking mileage of the H2.

I expect with their unique all American know-how the people at Hummer will figure out the best way to solve the gas mileage problem is to simply put in a forty gallon tank. Stupid is, stupid does...

Random notes from the long dark tea-time overseas

As promised here is a list (possibly quite long) of random stuff that occured to me during the two weeks I spent in England.

  • A letter to AdBusters has suggested guerilla tactic of putting "Out of Order" signs on vending machines, especially those selling high sugar drinks. This little piece of social engineering is apparently very successful since no-one no matter how thirsty wants to shovel coins into a machine that will probably eat their money instead of dispensing sugary beverages.
  • When departing for England I got to the airport a good two hours ahead of time like they always tell you to. Of course walking into the International Terminal at SFO I encountered a vast an empty wasteland of checkin desks. Unfortunately as I rounded the corner right at the end of the cavenous hall it turned out that Virgin had a huge line (although not as long as this line) I in front of it. The cause was apparently "our computers are not talking to the ticket printing computers" i.e. someone probably screwed up a network router somewhere. Consequently all tickets were being, shock-horror, hand written! And this was the cause of the monumental delay. I waited in line for an hour and probably would not have made it onto the plane if the computer problem hadn't been fixed after about 45 minutes. As it was I then had to wait another thirty minutes in the security line to take off my shoes and belt and watch and jacket and hat but not my pants... and by the time I got to the gate it was already boarding and there was no time for duty free, a snack or anything like that. Oh well, as they say - "expect the unexpected".
  • Having got the front of the aforementioned checkin line I was staggered when a Virgin employee came up to me and tried to sell me a bulkhead seat upgrade for $75. And that was just for one way... The tried it coming back to - the total would have been $150 or only slightly less than my entrie ticket cost. I was amazed that they are trying this kind of trick, I really didn't expect it from Virgin. After all on a 747 if you have a bulkhead seat you are likely to end up right next to the loos and face hordes of people (like me) milling around for eight hours trying to ward off deep vein thrombosis.
  • While on the plane I read something to the about Visa that just blew my mind. If you're a regular reader you'll know how the US national debt (that's debt, not deficit) is something like $7 trillion, or over $80,000 per family. Well apparently the folks at Visa (credit cards) handled transactions totally a stunning $362.4 trillion last year. But the really incredible thing is they only have a few thousand employees worldwide. So do the math - they cream of 2-3% (or maybe more) from each transaction which makes something like $6 trillion just from shoveling money around each year. They surely must have the highest revenue per employee of any company worldwide??? Next time you're wondering why credit card companies aren't worried by billions of dollars in credit card fraud you shouldn't be surprised, its a drop in the ocean compared to how much money they are making. And note, this figure doesn't include MasterCard, Amex and all those other smaller credit companies.
  • Of late I've found myself having more and more convesations with people about why mega-corporations like Wal-Mart and the like are bad for pretty much everyone except the executives running them and perhaps the shareholders who profit from their profits. The latest development seems to be that the UK supermarket chain Asda is now owned by Wal*Mart which lead to my sister-in-law asking me the leading question "So what's so bad about WalMart then?". This gave me an excellent opportunity to give her a run down on the apauling employee relations record of WalMart, their battle against unions, their terrible record on treatment of injured employees, and the very unpleasent anti-competive business practices the engage in with their suppliers. WalMart employs a staggering 900,000 people in the USA and 1.4 million worldwide so statistically most Americans know someone who works at or worked at WalMart. I do. Last year they made a net profit of $8 billion or almost $6000 per employee. Unfortunately most WalMart employees are languishing on minimum wage taking home a whopping $5-6 an hour and almost none of them have the benefit of full-time employment rights because the managers cunningly keeps their hours below the amount where they would qualify as full time employees. So in the end the only good thing about WalMart is the low prices and profit for shareholders (or if you're an executive the millions of dollars in compensation). Unfortunately the cost of communities that embrace WalMarts low prices as a god-send is undoubtedly a net negative when all factors are considered. They are just another example of a huge corporation siphoning billions of dollars out of our communities and redistributing to the top few percent that have no need for food stamps and working two or three jobs just to make ends meet.
  • While in Europe I got a much more balanced view of the world. Yes American issues are reported in the news, almost every day on the TV and certainly every day in the papers. However, even when accounting for the bias towards local stories you get a much greater balance between American, European, Asian and news from the rest of the world Indeed given that the European Union now has a larger population than the USA, and both India and China have populations of over one billion its a wonder how long the USA can maintain its empire building streak before collapsing into obscurity like the UK, France, Spain, Russia, and all those other empire wannabes did in previous centuries. The USA has long been lauded as the poster child of efficiency but recent figures are starting to suggest that Europe, with all it advantages of a superior standard of living is getting very close to current US efficiency standard. And there may even be reason to believe that much of Americans economic growth has been bolstered significantly by increases in efficiency at the expense of living standards vs. adopting inherently more efficient systems.
  • I read an article on how Vietnamese catfish farmers realized that opening of trade borders meant they could sell their catfish into the USA and vastly undercut local suppliers. As they began to corner the market the USA catfish farmers retaliated and forced the Vietnames fish to be sold under a different name. While both fish were technically "catfish" the Vietnamese were of a different species than those farmed in the USA. This opened the door for the FDA to rule that only US catfish could be sold as "catfish". To add insult to injury the ITC then decided that the USA could levy a stiff tariff to ensure even the relabled product could not undercut the local product. This to me is yet another fine example of how globalization is okay just so long as a US company is in the chain somewhere to milk some cash out of the newly created international trade. Just how long will it be before India and China finally wake and realize that the WTO and GATT treaties with the USA are only useful if an American corporation is in the chain somewhere to suck up a tidy profit from the cross border trade. After all, if some overseas sneaker company started successfully selling its locally produced product in the USA just how long do you think it would be before Nike was calling for trade tariffs against them?
  • Finally my hat goes off to Roy Disney who's resignation letter pointed out that Disney is now perceived as a company that
    "is rapacious, soul-less, and always looking for the "quick buck" rather than the long-term value which is leading to a loss of public trust."
    Well tar and feather me and roll me down the Matterhorn but surely truer words could not have been spoken? Couldn't he have been speaking about almost any Fortune 500 company? Of course Roy Disney will now be ostricised and marginalized as some freak of the excutive world who "just didn't get it" but I think he "got it" exactly. For years now that confounded Disney mouse has caused a very negative reaction in me, not disimilar to that exhibited by Cayce Pollard in William Gibson's "Pattern Recognition". It has nothing whatsoever to do with an aversion for mice, but entirely about Disney selling its soul somewhere along the line to become an icon of all that is bland, phoney and exploitative in America. So that said, if I ever meet Roy Disney I'd certainly shake his hand and buy him a drink for saying what was really on his mind..

Once more unto the Tea-Time

If you didn't know already I have recently returned from a trip to the Mother Country where I spent two weeks doing little else except drink tea. Its such a pastime over there I had forgotten how it was to drink a half dozen or so cups of the stuff in one day. So you would think such a trip would surely have me bursting with things to blog about, well it has but somehow I haven't managed to until today.

In the end I started to get tired of hearing "When are you going to blog again?", to the point where I've started to wonder about it myself. While I have managed a few quips over on JohnnyTheo none of my copious notes made while on the road have made it into digital print. In the end I think it was the shear volume of notes, and the loss of immediacy that killed the urge to put fingers to keyboard. I really should have just written the entries in full there and then, and done a copy and paste when I got back. As a solution I think I'm just going to dump my notes into the next entry and get back to the normal programme...

Friday, November 14, 2003

The devil is in the operating system... maybe

Over the past week I've been several calls or messages a day from a friend who has been trying to figure out why his laptop takes forever to startup. The calls range from excited "I've found it" type messages to depressed resignation to the fact that "it" whatever it may be, will never be found. Apparently the laptop didn't use to behave this way so as the resident PC expert in his life we suspected anything from a configuration problem, virus to spyware. Either way, to the uninformed one might conclude his laptop is possessed by some nasty daemon. Now this guy is not a computer neophyte, he's written an real-time operating system, debugged embedded systems with his bare hands, and been a CTO of a multi-billion dollar company. But somewhere along the line he resigned from his duty of keeping up to date with the details of computer maintenance and that just about coincided with Microsoft Windows becoming the prevalent desktop platform.

So in the past week I've given him the low down on his registry, where all the startup program hide and how to use 'msconfig' or 'regedit'. I've given him Norton System Works (tip buy: last years version from eBay, a snip at $6 or less!) to clean up his invalid registry entries and remove IE plugins and ActiveX cruft, Ad-Aware to scan for spyware, and pointed him to Sandra 2004 to check all his system hardware configuration. Giving remote assistance its a slow process, you know how it is trying to get an exact explanation of the "all I did was" or "I didn't change anything" scenarios that inevitbly preceed dire straits. To date we've removed a lot of redundant cruft, and found one spyware program NewDotNet which was something particularly incidious lurking in his network stack that even I hadn't heard of yet. I guess I should have, however I tend to stay well away from programs that contain any spyware - its been a couple of years now since I fell victim to anything like that.

However, as far as I know, the truth is still out there and the laptop is still misbehaving. I'm hoping to avoid a "laying on of hands" session - if I'm lucky I'll depart on my vacation before that becomes necessary. I know this guy has probably spent the best part of 20 to 40 hours on this problem now and I'm about ready to recommend he back up the personal data and reinstall the OS, or at least try a system repair.

In the mean time I'm reminded that unauthorized modifications to the system code is one of the things that the next major version of Windows aka "Longhorn" is supposed to cure once and for all. Apparently much maligned data protection features that are being built in at the hardware level will also be turned to protect the operating system itself from modification. The use of data protection for enforcing copyright protection is highly contentious - it seems, that like on the freeway, everyone wants to be free to break the law even though they know its illegal to do so. Maybe that is just part of freedom - freedom to transgress the rules of society for whatever reason and freedom to experience the loss of freedom. However using data protection to protect the neophyte, or not so neophyte computer user from having to think about viruses and spyware is an emminently sensible thing to do. I'm not entirely sure how the protection of the OS from viruses and the like will work - if a program wants to install and pops up the classic license dialog with some disclaimer in 1point text way down at the bottom, how is the OS supposed to differentiate legitimate user approved installations of software from installation of spyware or other updates of drivers etc.?

Maybe future versions of Windows will, by default, be configured in such a way that only software digitally signed by Microsoft can be installed. After my last week of experience I'm begining to wonder if this isn't such a bad idea. For a certain class of computer users I'm sure there is a very strong case to be made for having the computer pre-configured and permanently locked in a mode where system maintenance, including installing programs can only be done remotely by a Microsoft support person or agent. This might actually save a bundle of cash on calls from people who went in and deleted half their system files, or messed with the registry or something like that. These things can be painfully slow to diagnose and debug and its probably just better to never let people get into this mess in the first place. So what about freedom? Well sometimes you've gotta earn freedom or pay a price to keep it. In this case I think 95% of computer users really don't need the freedom to install anything but approved off the shelf packages and should be given a discount for enduring blissful ignorance of the world of pain that awaits them once they start installing at will all the random junk that is lurking out their on the Internet. One benefit of having such a system could be that a higher degree of accountability could then be placed on software vendors for damage their software may cause. After installing a certain package the system becomes "unstable" its much easier to point the blame and seek recompense or at the very least remedial action. A company could no longer shirk its responsiblity and blame viruses or some other user action for the problems.

In the mean time I wont hold my breath waiting for Longhorn, and I'll continue to swaddle myself with anti-virus protection, firewalls, and the usual armoury of system utilities that are necessary to keep clean and free in the age of Internet Enlightenment.

Wednesday, November 12, 2003

Unsung superheros: Knee Defender!

I've often contemplated how useful defensive tactics against compulsive airline seat recliners would be. Unfortunately I never thought about it until after the seat slammed down into my knees. What I found most interesting was that in business class its even worse - the seats recline so far if you are sitting by the window you have to crawl over your neighbors lap to escape. However my favourite superhero Knee Defender comes to the rescue! As with the best in ventions its small, disarmingly simple and cheap. I love their little courtesy card to explain the predicament to the passenger in front.

Now all I'm waiting for is the Back Defender that prevents the annoying little oik behind you from kicking your seat compulsively.

Tuesday, November 11, 2003

The fundamental interconnectedness of being

With a blog named "The long dark tea-time of the soul" you'd expect me to believe in the fundamental interconnectedness of things. However it never ceases to amaze me when life really does appear to be fundamentally interconnected. Tonight I went to a Bay Area development planning meeting in San Francisco. Its one of those things that until a few months ago I would never have considered attending. But thats where you end up when you start taking an interesting in your own neighborhood and wondering just who is making all the important decisions and why.

So I'm riding the elevator to the 26th floor of some non-descript downtown skyscraper late at night and I think "wow, this is just like in that Josh Kornbluth movie, 'Haiku Tunnel' when Josh is skulking around some downtown skyscrapers late at night trying to post those letters... " I sit through the five hour planning meeting watching a bunch of planning commissions make decisions about how the city will be developed. At 11:30pm I get out of the meeting - five hours without food, drink or coffee (do I qualify for Survivor yet?) - and I take BART back home. Then as I get off BART at West Oakland I bump into an old friend of my girlfriend whom I haven't seen in over a year or more, and who just got laid off from Salon Magazine and hence is just about to leave town for Los Angeles. So it was probably just the last chance I would ever have of bumping into her and certainly the last opportunity to invite her to come to my girlfriends Art Exhibition (shameless plug). Even more bizarrely she just happened to know my travelling companion from the days when he worked from the City of Oakland.

Then I go home and I decide on a whim to listen to my voice mail that's been piling up and my friend is complaining about some 5Mb email he's been jamming up my mail servers with. So I go checking my server logs and there I notice that Josh Kornbluth was trying to send me an email today but failed because I'd retired my old email address due to too much spam. I send Josh some email telling him my new email address and he gets right back to me almost immediately and from his reply I find out Josh just started his own blog about taxation this week. So I'm posting a comment about taxation of The Rolling Stones on his blog when I think: "Wait a minute - wasn't I thinking about Josh earlier this evening riding the elevator to the meeting in 50 California?"

And just then I realized I knew what I would blog about this evening.

Friday, November 07, 2003

So IQs did drop sharply

Following my previous post about Diebolds "disconcerting" news I'd like to publicly question the intelligence of those in Alameda County who bought their system. Apparently the fact that Diebold had applied an unauthorized (and uncertified) patch to their voting machines was not detected until an audit done after the most recent election.

What amazes me is that anyone buying an electronic voting system could allow one where the manufacturer could apply a code patch without this being a) detected and b) rejected before voting commenced. Just how hard is it for the voting system to require an independent verification that the code being executed is that which was certified? If the checksum of the code being executed doesn't match that of the code certified the machine should be not be usable for voting. Period.

Sigh.

The Bellevue Bounty Hunters

I found it amusing that Microsoft is now offering two $250k rewards to anyone who can deliver recent virus auhors. Such bounty hunter tactics may get a lot of press but I have my doubts about how successful they will ever be (remember the $25M bounty on Saddam?).

Based on the estimated economic damage done by viruses and worms I don't think it will be long before someone is offering the following counter bounties to capture various big business evil-doers:

  • $1 billion for the person who added support for VB script attachments in Outlook
  • $1 billion for each person who did an unchecked copy of data to a buffer
  • $1 billion for the person who, after adding all the security to WinXP decided the default install should disable most of it
  • $1 billion plus tar and feathering for the person who decided to market Oracle's database as "unbreakable" only to have it hacked on the launch day

Wednesday, November 05, 2003

The Hitchens vs. Danner Smackdown Part II

I just finished watching the second Hitchens vs. Danner debate, click here to do so for yourself. I watched the first one in person before the war and it was interesting to hear if opinions had changed.

For those that don't know Christopher Hitchens is a very bright intellectual with a ton of facts at his finger tips. He's been studying and writing about politicts, foreign policy and all kinds of things for a long time. He even wrote a book on Mother Teresa and frequently manages quick and witty come backs. Of Hitchens, one of my friends said "He's just too clever for his own good" and thats because he can present such well reasoned arguments you'll find yourself following and believing his train of thought until at once you realize you completely disagree with his conclusion. Then you feel tricked and apt to not trust his arguments any more. Danner is also intelligent and well read, written and traveled. However Danner does not present that "snobbish intellectual" front that Hitchens sometimes does.

So basically it went exactly the way I thought. Hitchens still saying "it was justified - we had to do it" and Danner saying "Its a huge mess, I told you so and the US government is going to have a really hard, if not impossible time fixing it".

Danner spared Hitchens the embarasement of reminding him of his predictions of a very quick shock and awe victory followed in quick succession by democracy. It would be interesting to go back and listen to the original debate.

My conclusions are:

  • a) I don't believe Hitchens premise that this was the only route the USA could take, and that they had to take it.
  • b) I believe Danner's statements on how dangerous it is right now, and how hopeless the USA's efforts to restore relative safety are.
  • c) Pulling out is not an option and because of b) there will be a protracted, very bloody and very expensive military occupation of Iraq.
  • d) Even if the government sticks with it, the American people will tire of the cost of keeping, or trying to keep peace in Iraq long before the government does. This will probably lead to some very unfortunate consequences.
  • e) I just don't buy Hitchens assertion that the American people are safer now than they were. The escalation of hatred towards the USA and the race to acquire nuclear arms by small nations are very concrete indications that big stick policies don't work. You reap what you sow...
  • f) The palpable deception of the American people over pretty much every fact relating to this invasion was disgusting and I didn't even hear Hitchens say "yes, but it was necessary". It has only helped to bring the American government into ill-repute.

I have thought all along that the USA should have been using its power to enforce the UN as a just and reliable enforcer of world peace and router of tyrants who cause genocide and commit other crimes against humanity. However it is clear to me that only the "eye for an eye" tactic for "peace keeping" is currently in vogue. Unfortunately we know from so many, many conflict situations around the world that tit-for-tat violence leads nowhere but a bloody spiral down...

The people of Iraq deserve better. Saddam was an evil saddistic tyrant, but he's still out there and many immitators have rushed in to fill the void. No, I didn't have any great plan to get him out of power and to stop the blood letting at home. But I would have found a compromise to get UN backing and support, and I would have been upfront with the true cost and arrange for a large enough force and sufficient forward planning to make the road to stability, peace and independence again a smoother one.

But ultimately is the USA or even the combined efforts of the UN even in a position to consider such benevolance towards every country that is suffering under the remaining tyrants of the world? Their efforts in Afghanistan clearly show that UN involvement alone is not sufficient and that billions of dollars does not even come close to the true cost of peace. If we want to buy peace for every country that threatens us or does not meet up to our expectatins of democracy imagine that it will be tens if not hundreds of trillions of dollars that are required. and will peace that is bought ever be lasting? Somehow I doubt it. There are probably easier but much slower ways to achieve world peace. They may require patience, diplomacy and nerves of steel. But witness the crumbling of the Soviet Union as a case in point. Or the brokered peace in Northern Ireland.

Right now America is clearly following a foreign policy that is threatening, ambiguous and dangerous around the world. People asked "why do they hate us?" after 9/11, and I'm sure a great number of people still ask themselves that question. I don't think we'll ever be able to rest easy at home until the majority of Americans understand why agressive, preemptive, unilateral foreign policies are the touchstone of resentment and hatred. Unfortunately that may be a long time coming for America and the world as a whole, we only have to look at our internal situation to realize that. But that's a whole different story...

From his own mouth

"Trying to eliminate Saddam, extending the ground war into an occupation of Iraq, would have violated our guideline about not changing objectives in midstream, engaging in "mission creep," and would have incurred incalculable human and political costs. Apprehending him was probably impossible. We had been unable to find Noriega in Panama, which we knew intimately. We would have been forced to occupy Baghdad and, in effect, rule Iraq. The coalition would instantly have collapsed, the Arabs deserting it in anger and other allies pulling out as out as well. Under those circumstances, there was no viable "exit strategy" we could see, violating another of our principles. Furthermore, we had been self-consciously trying to set a pattern for handling aggression in the post-Cold War world. Going in and occupying Iraq, thus unilaterally exceeding the United Nations' mandate, would have destroyed the precedent of international response to aggression that we hoped to establish. Had we gone the invasion route, the United States could conceivably still be an occupying power in a bitterly hostile land."
Brent Scowcroft and George H. W. Bush's A World Transformed (1998).